Where They Stand:
A look at What Elected Officials Think About NYRI Proposed 400-kilovolt Electric Transmission Line
Name
Office
View of 400-KV Line
Sen. Charles Schumer
US Senator
Sen. Schumer has called on NYRI officials to answer
a number of questions and also to hold more
informational meetings
Sen. Hillary Clinton
US Senator
Sen. Clinton wrote to the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission asking it to hold meetings in
communities along the proposed power line route.
Opposes federal designation as NIETC.
Rep. John McHugh
Congressman
"I am adamantly opposed" and he said NYRI
deserves no special treatment from federal
department of Energy
Rep. Sherwood Boehlert
Congressman
As reported by the Utica Observer Dispatch, Boehlert
said, “...I am doubtful that NYRI’s plan is the proper
course of action, particularly since they have failed to
provide the public with basic, necessary information.”
Most recently called it a "cockamamie scheme".
Michael Arcuri
Candidate for Boehlert's
seat
“I stand with the people of the 24th district to oppose
this proposed power line. Although NYRI promised
economic, environmental, and reliability benefits, the
company has not yet engaged with the public on
these matters, even during public meetings. There
are a lot of questions that remain unanswered and I
urge the Public Service Commission not to approve
this project.”
Gov. George Pataki
Governor
A spokesman said the Governor would not make any
comment until there is a PSC Article VII filing, which it
did May 31. This from the Utica Observer Dispatch of
June 4: "A spokesman for Pataki said the governor
hadn't had the chance to review the power line
question thoroughly, but he would likely have a
position in the future."

In a recent speech on the need for a national energy
policy, Pataki told the National Press Club that New
York State needed more tranmssion lines.   
Attorney General Elliot Spitzer
Attorney General and
Democrat Candidate for
Governor
This from the Syracuse Post-Standard of Aug. 19,
2006:
During a brief question-and-answer period, Spitzer
said that as attorney general he had called for
improvements in the state's power distribution system.

"That doesn't mean New York Regional Interconnect
is a good idea," he said.

In fact,
Spitzer said the project to carry
electricity from Upstate to Downstate isn't going
to happen because there is too much local
opposition.

"Let's find an alternative," he said.
John Faso
Republican Candidate for
Governor
At a meeting in Clayville Aug. 8 Faso said he is totally
opposed to the project and favors generation closer
to the source of energy consumption.

This from the June 4 Utica Observer Dispatch: "I
would certainly try to discuss with them and make
sure that any such transmission proposal was
compatible with community interest and our overall
needs for energy distribution. Faso also said he
believes there is a need for more energy generation
downstate."
Sen. Joseph Bruno
NYS Senate Majority
Leader
"...  it is my strong belief that the power line plan
should not go forward."
Sen. Dave Valesky
State Senator
Spokesman May 19 said the senator opposes the
project.

“…grown increasingly skeptical and concerned about
New York Regional Interconnect’s plan to build a high
voltage power line connecting Oneida County to
Orange County.”
Sen. Ray Meier
State Senator
"We need to put them in a forum that they can't script
and can't control if we're ever going to get straight
answers. We want to ask direct questions and get
direct answers."

"It's property values, the environmental concerns,
"but the real issue is …you're going to draw power
out of the power pool we use and drive prices up
here."
Assemblyman Bill Magee
State Assemblyman
Magee wrote in a letter to PSC Chairman William
Flynn that NYRI's proposal would "essentially rape
the landscape and viewshed of Upstate New York.
While I understand the need for additional power in
the Downstate area, I have great apprehension
about the placement of these power towers through
so many environmentally sensitive, historically
significant and agriculturally oriented areas."

"I don’t see where there’s any benefit to the people I
represent, so why should I be for it?"
Assemblywoman Roann Destito
State Assemblywoman
Strongly opposed and has brought an Assembly
Energy Committee hearing to Marcy for Aug. 23.
Rocky DiVeronia
Chairman Madison
County Board of
Supervisors
Has become one of the most vocal county leaders
opposing NYRI and is a leader of the Communities
Against Regional Interconnect (CARI).

“I am totally opposed to this project.”
Lead Madison County Board of Supervisors in recent
vote against the project.
Walt Jaquay
Hamilton Town Supervisor
"There is a not a member of the town board who is
for this project." Comment just before board
unanimously approved a moratorium resolution
Loren Corbin
Brookfield Town
Supervisor
Adamantly oppossed
Jim Golstein
Lebanon Town Supervisor
Adamantly opposed; his board passed a resolution of
opposition to the project and solidarity with towns of
Hamilton and Brookfield
Jim Walter, executive director
Madison County Tourism
“Madison County Tourism, Inc. does not plan to take
a stand for or against the power line that is proposed
to cut across Hamilton and Brookfield. It would have
little effect on the tourism economy good or bad.  
Tim Julian
Mayor of Utica
Led a walk-out of audience members at NYRI
meeting in Utica May 9. On Friday, he said he's
asked state and federal officials to block New York
Regional Interconnect from starting the 200-mile
project. City of Utica June 29 initiated a lawsuit
against the railroad saying it did not legally execute
its contract with NYRI for development rights.
Joe Griffo
Oneida County Executive
He has written state and federal officials opposing
the plan.  Although he held out a willingness to
discuss the project once all the facts are laid on the
table for all people impacted by the project to review,
Griffo said until there are satisfactory answers, he
cannot support the project.
Dave Hall
President, CEO of
Chenango County
Chamber of Commerce
One of the leaders of opposition in Chenango
County.
Elsewhere
Sen. John Bonacic
R-Mount Hope
Successfully introduced legislation opposing the
use of eminent domain by NYRI.

"It seems NYRI is trying to circumvent state laws
by going to federal officials. We want to stop
that." Successfully introduced a bill eliminating
the use of eminent domain by NYRI.
Sen. James Seward
R-Milford
He said he sees "little reason to support " the
NYRI proposal. Condemned the project during
Senate Energy Committee hearing but voted
against Bonacic's eminent domain legislation.
Sen. Thomas Libous
R-Binghamton
"I’m going to stand side-by-side with my
constituents in Chenango County to fight big
business and big government who are trying to
shove this down our throats.This project
contains no benefits to our community, and it
would only obstruct our landscape and decrease
our property values," Libous said.
Assemblyman Gary
Finch
R-Springport (district includes
Sherburne)
"I can’t support this project unless they agree to
bury it."
Assemblyman Cliff
Crouch
R-Guilford
"My people are opposed to this project, and I’m
with them."
Home                                        Power Play